Can You Take Supplements While Fasting?

October 06, 2020

Can You Take Supplements While Fasting?

In this article:

  • What is fasting and how does it work?
  • Different types of fasting
  • Which beverages won't break a fast?
  • Acceptable vitamins & supplements to take while fasting
  • Nutritional do's & don't's while fasting
  • Supplements less likely to break a fast

How does fasting work?

Our bodies have two sources of fuel - the calories that we eat, and fat stored in our bodies. When we don’t eat, the body then turns to stored fat for fuel, resulting in fat loss. The body is either storing food energy (feasting) or we are burning it (fasting). When fasting and feasting work together in harmony, there is generally no weight gain. Sounds simple right?

The body can pull from three different kinds of materials to create energy: protein, carbohydrates, and fat stores. All three provide energy for the body but at different rates and through different pathways. The body only has a small amount of glycogen (stored sugar) that it can pull from. Once this has been emptied, it moves right on over to protein and lipid. However, it is more efficient to use lipid (or fat mass) than protein because there is a lot more energy in fat mass than in muscle mass. Sound surprising? So, for the most part, the body will begin to burn fat once all carbohydrates have been used up. At this moment when the body is burning only fat, we believe that it is truly in the fasting state; this is just around 48 hours after the last meal. The way we see the body burning fat is actually through the unique molecules called ketone bodies. As fat burning increases, so do ketone bodies. We call this state “ketosis”. If the body is left in this state for too long, which is to say if the body continues to not have nutrition coming in, then the body will begin to starve. If left in starvation, then the body will eventually become malnourished.

Types of fasting

In simple terms, fasting is the omission of food. However, it truly is much more than just that! What are the benefits of fasting? What determines the fasting state is actually a combination and quantity of the specific macro and micronutrients of the foods we eat. Luckily, there is more than one way to fast, but there is only one that has been shown to induce rejuvenation and regeneration.

  • Time Restricted Feeding (TRF)

TRF is a form of intake restriction that is specifically focused on when and how long eating occurs rather than macronutrients. This type of fasting is based on the theory that our ancestors likely fed during daylight with limited resources and fasted during the night. Interestingly, this is controlled by what we call the circadian system. The circadian system oscillates every ~24 hours in a rhythm that enables organisms to respond to the light-dark cycle, which coincides with food accessibility. Today, this system has been disrupted due to long work hours, artificial light exposure, and haphazard eating behavior. To get back control of this system, we can mimic the natural circadian pattern by restricting feeding to a certain period of time.

  • Intermittent Fasting (IF)

Intermittent fasting is a form of fasting where the individual will fast for an interval of time, usually no more than 48hrs, and then eat normally for the remaining period of time throughout the week. The most common example of this is known as the “5:2” diet, where the individual restricts calories for 2 days, consecutive or not, and then eats normally for the remaining 5 days. Other daily fast to eat schedules include 14:10 (fast for 14 hours, then eat all your calories within 10 hours), 20:4, and 16:8; the 16:8 method is the most common because it fits into most modern working lifestyles in the US. This fasting method has been linked to a range of potential health benefits, including short-term increases in human growth hormone (HGH) and changes in gene expression. It is also said that other benefits of intermittent fasting include helping those who have been diagnosed with Type 2 diabetes, because it helps manage your sugar intake and lower your blood glucose. Many people choose to fast when they have diabetes and especially when they want to eventually stop taking medicine for it.

Religious fasting

Fasting as a way to regain or refocus spirituality is common in many religions. That’s right, Jesus was into a fast. Religions and philosophies that practice fasting include: Buddhism, Christianity, Islam, Judaism, Taoism, Jainism, and Hinduism. Fasting can last for just a few hours or even a few weeks, usually with practitioners eating at night. Different religions may fast differently or at different times. For example, within Christianity, there are several different denominations that fast at different times. Catholics do not eat meat on Fridays during Lent, while Coptic Christians, the main form of Christianity in Egypt, fast for different durations for a total of 210 days throughout the year. They have eight main fasts, and each lasts for a different duration and restricts the diet in a unique way. For others, fasting is meant to bring worshippers closer to God through steady remembrance, reflection, and sacrifice. Daily fasting, combined with five daily prayers and extended evening prayers, challenges worshippers to focus on their actions, deeds, and thoughts, rather than on material desires and instant gratification.

Fasting is a reset for the mind, body and soul. Muslims are expected to show self-control and deeper spirituality during Ramadan. It's also a month of gratitude. By abstaining from food and water during the day, the faithful are reminded of those less fortunate. Each night during Ramadan, mosques and aid organizations set up tents and tables to serve free evening meals for the poor.

Keto Nutrition & Ketosis

Many of you will have heard of the keto diet which is a low-carb, high-fat diet. Ketosis lowers blood sugar and insulin levels and shifts the body’s metabolism away from carbs and towards fat and ketones. A ketogenic diet is an effective way to lose weight and lower risk factors for disease. There are several versions of the keto diet. The standard ketogenic diet (SKD) is the most researched and most recommended. This is a very low-carb, moderate-protein, and high-fat diet. It typically contains 75% fat, 20% protein, and only 5% carbs. The diet can actually be so satiating that you can lose weight without counting calories or obsessing over your food intake.

Fasting Period

There is no single way to fast, meaning that the duration of your fasted state is up to you. There are different methods that exist. For example, the 5:2 pattern says to restrict your calorie intake for two days per week (500 calories per day for women and 600 for men). The 6:1 pattern is similar to the 5:2, but there’s only one day of reduced calorie intake instead of two. The Eat Stop Eat” method is a 24-hour complete fast that you do 1–2 times per week. Last but not least, the 16:8 pattern involves only consuming food in an eight-hour window and fasting for 16 hours a day, every day of the week.

Liquids that don't break a fast

Unlike food, when you consume apple cider vinegar or coffee, for example, the fast is not broken, and the benefits of fasting can actually be enhanced. Both coffee and apple cider vinegar promote AMP-activated kinase (AMPK) within the body. AMPK is an enzyme that plays a role in cellular energy homeostasis by activating glucose and fatty acid uptake and oxidation when cellular energy is low. Many researchers studying the benefits of intermittent fasting in conjunction with consuming non-food products like apple cider vinegar believe that AMPK activations are extended, furthering the benefit of intermittent fasting. There are many vitamins in apple cider vinegar including vitamins B1, B2, B6, biotin, folic acid, niacin, pantothenic acid, and vitamin C. It also contains minerals such as calcium, iron, magnesium, phosphorus, potassium, and sodium. Together, these minerals and vitamins provide support to the body to strengthen the nervous and immune systems, while supporting overall health and body optimization.

Putting a slice or two of lemon, cucumber, or mint in your water doesn’t have enough of an effect on your blood sugar or insulin levels to break your fast. Sure, lemons and other citrus products do contain calories in the form of fructose, which does stimulate the liver to break a fasted state, but eating and drinking aren’t treated the same in the digestive process. The most important thing to remember is to listen to your body; most of the benefits of fasting can still be achieved even with breaking the fast up to 100-150 calories. Add a splash of milk to your coffee or snack on some vegetables - there are no absolute rules when it comes to what’s right for your body.

Vitamins & supplements while fasting

Generally, you can continue taking supplements and still get the fat-burning benefits of an intermittent fast. However, first consider that if you’re only consuming water and/or black coffee while fasting, some vitamins (like B vitamins and zinc) can make you feel nauseous on an empty stomach. If you are going to take any of these, you probably want to save them for your eating windows (and if you’re not sure how they’ll react on an empty stomach, definitely wait). It's important to be mindful of your supplements because some of them can affect your body’s function during your fast.

For example, they can:

  • Drop your blood sugar levels, thus decreasing your energy and giving you brain fog
  • Raise your insulin levels which takes you out of ketosis (the whole point of fasting, for many people)
  • Pass through your body without being absorbed if not taken with food
  • Make you nauseous (if taken on an empty stomach)

If you’re taking a vitamin supplement, consider this - vitamins break down into two categories:

Fat-soluble: These vitamins should be eaten with fat-containing food in order for your body to absorb them. They include vitamin A, vitamin D, vitamin E, and vitamin K. The body stores fat-soluble vitamins in the liver and body fat. Taking these in windows when you aren’t consuming food with fat in it means you’re less likely to absorb them, so there’s no real point. While fasting for less than 5 days, you’ll be burning your own body fat and getting vitamins that way.

Water-soluble: These vitamins are not stored in your body but are excreted during the day if you drink liquids. They include: B-complex vitamins, like B1, B2, B3, etc, folic acid, vitamin C, and many others. You can take these on an empty stomach, but again, they might upset it. If you’re doing short term fasting over the course of a few days, you aren’t likely to deplete enough of these to affect your health negatively. You only need to consider supplementing if you’re fasting for more than a week.

For those who are supplementing during fasting, it's suggested to not take in too much vitamin C and vitamin E. Too much vitamin C can cause kidney stones and too much vitamin E can cause blood-clotting problems. L-tyrosine is one alternative because it may help you feel stronger and mentally sharper while fasting. You can also take this on an empty stomach.

It is said that the longer you fast, the more likely you are to need supplementation, but most importantly, pay attention to how you feel and make sure your nutritionist or health professional is aware of how you are fasting. When you do eat, make sure to eat a variety of foods, or implement a diet like the mediterranean diet, which is associated with reduced risk factors in a number of health conditions like type 2 diabetes and blood pressure.

Do's & Don'ts while fasting

The Dos

Figure out when your feeding window and fasting periods will be.

There are a few different ways to fast. Some of the most popular ways to start intermittent fasting are the following:

  • The 5:2 method: Five days eating, two days fasting
  • The 16/8 method: Fasting window up to 16 hours, eating for 8 hours.
  • The daily fasting method

Listen to your body

Starting a fast whether it’s a full day or just a few hours can be hard. The key to being successful is to listen to your body. Start small and if you start to feel any negative side effects, pay attention to that and eat something if you feel the need.

Eat Fibrous and Fatty Foods

Foods that contain high quality of fiber content are more filling and if paired with foods that are higher in healthy fats, they will keep you fuller longer. Examples include oats, peanut butter, and protein powder, or you can make smoothies out of all of them.

The Don’ts

Don’t restrict calories during the eating period

The purpose of the eating period is to give your body the energy it needs to function. It can be tempting to restrict calories during this eating period but that can derail your progress and cause your body to crave more food and break your fast before you’re ready.

Don’t binge-eat during the eating period

The opposite of restricting calories is binging. This can also be detrimental because you will increase calorie consumption and slow down the benefits of fasting altogether. If eating disorders have been an issue in the past, fasting might not be the right nutrition plan for you.  

Don’t overexert your body while fasting

When you’re fasting, your body is lacking the normal amount of energy you typically get from your daily meals. While it’s okay to workout as you normally would, it’s important to not burn out your body to the point of exhaustion. The key to intermittent fasting is to be mindful of what you’re eating and when. Listen to your body and give yourself a good chance of succeeding by starting with a realistic ratio of fasting to eating windows.

Supplements less likely to break a fast

Some people choose to take supplements while fasting to ensure adequate vitamin and mineral intake. Fasting too frequently could lead to nutrient deficiencies if your diet is already low in vitamins and minerals.

Focus on replenishing your electrolytes and keep up any vitamins you already take if possible. The longer you fast, the more likely you are to need supplementation. Most importantly, if you want to have a successful and healthy fast, pay attention to how you feel and make sure your doctor knows you’re fasting.

Summary Points

  • In order to keep our weight balanced, it is necessary to align feasting (eating windows) and fasting (calorie burning) phases
  • There are different types of fasting, including Time restricted fasting (TRF) IF, religious fasting, and keto
  • Some beverages or liquids are acceptable during fasting periods including coffee and apple cider vinegar
  • It is important to get enough energy during your feeding period for your body to perform during the rest of the day
  • There are supplements, such as pure collagen, that won't significantly compromize your fast, but will provide a number of needed benefits

Article References:

  1. https://fastinglane.com/fasting-101
  2. https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/ketogenic-diet-101#:~:text=The%20ketogenic%20diet%20is%20a,a%20metabolic%20state%20called%20ketosis.
  3. https://www.fastingblog.com/types-of-fasting/
  4. https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/6-ways-to-do-intermittent-fasting
  5. https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/how-to-fast
  6. https://www.amandean.com/blogs/news/collagen-intermittent-fasting-101-does-collagen-break-fasting?_pos=3&_sid=9bb8d0bd3&_ss=r
  7. https://www.webmd.com/diabetes/fasting-diabetes
  8. https://culturalawareness.com/fasting-around-the-world/
  9. https://www.dailysabah.com/religion/2019/05/06/ramadan-101-everything-you-need-to-know-about-fasting-and-traditions-during-islams-holiest-month
  10. https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/ketogenic-diet-101#types
  11. https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/how-to-lose-weight-as-fast-as-possible
  12. https://swolverine.com/blogs/blog/apple-cider-vinegar-intermittent-fasting-what-you-need-to-know-for-a-successful-fast
  13. https://www.bulletproof.com/diet/intermittent-fasting/intermittent-fasting-guide/
  14. https://medium.com/zero-fasting/should-you-supplement-while-fasting-2621585992dd
  15. https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/149090
  16. https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/how-to-fast#section1
  17. https://www.amandean.com/blogs/recipes/jennifer-garners-collagen-smoothie-leaked?_pos=8&_sid=9bb8d0bd3&_ss=r
  18. https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/what-breaks-a-fast#breaking-your-fast
  19. https://www.amandean.com/blogs/news/krill-vs-marine-algae-what-s-the-best-supplement-source-for-omega-3s?_pos=1&_sid=6a0181201&_ss=r
  20. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4810759/
  21. https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/10-benefits-of-creatine
  22. https://www.amandean.com/products/collagen-peptides-packets-box-of-30-individual-stick-packs-grass-fed-hydrolyzed-collagen-protein-powder?_pos=7&_sid=9bb8d0bd3&_ss=r
  23. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5385025/




Also in Amandean Wellness Center

How exactly does Marine Collagen grow your hair & nails?
How exactly does Marine Collagen grow your hair & nails?

October 12, 2020

There is no shortage of topical skincare creams, serums, and gadgets that claim to restore your skin's youthfulness and glow. We're practically swimming in them! While some can bring impressive results, they fail to realize one thing - just like the health of your internal organs, you have to first address your nutrition before you can see any significant results. This is what makes marine collagen a dietary supplement you don't want to miss out on. The health benefits of this powerful collagen protein don't stop at the gym - marine collagen can help to alleviate joint pain, improve gut health, and enhance your everyday skin and nail routines! The only trouble is, we can't get enough of it. As we age, our body produces less and less collagen leaving our skin a little more dull and wrinkle-prone, and our hair and nails more brittle. Keep reading to learn about how collagen supplements can improve the health and appearance of your skin and nails with every scoop!

Continue Reading

How Stress Affects Your Sexual Health
How Stress Affects Your Sexual Health

October 12, 2020

Intimacy and stress rarely mix. Between the stresses that come from our jobs, our families, the news, and health issues, it is no wonder that our sex lives suffer. Today we take a deep dive into the science behind our libidos, a breakdown of what happens to our bodies and our hormones when our stress levels increase & decrease, and what you can do in your daily life to manage your stress levels more effectively.

Continue Reading

Ingredient Spotlight: Vegan Omega-3
Ingredient Spotlight: Vegan Omega-3

October 08, 2020

For our vegan and vegetarian friends out there, we know a plant-based lifestyle comes with its challenges. Plant-based diets are becoming more mainstream due to a growing population of vegetarians and vegans, and many of us who are choosing more environmentally-friendly nutrition Even those of us who are not vegetarians can still practice a healthy lifestyle filled with lots of fruits and veggies to better our general health. No matter what your food preferences may be, there are certain nutrients that your body requires. Omega-3 especially! These healthy essential fats are not produced by the body on its own but are necessary for how your body is structured and how it functions.

Continue Reading